Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Stock Market Manipulation - US Markets and elsewhere

Retail brokerage customers generally never learn that they paid money for something that failed to be delivered to their accounts. That is because retail customers’ brokerage account statements do not reveal whether delivery takes place; even when no shares are delivered at settlement, share entitlements are still credited to the buyer’s account. Those credited share entitlements then trade in the market as if they were real shares issued by the company. - WorldAffairsJournal Regulation (Spring 2008)

Huh? What's the above about? It's about the practice of selling shares without owning any shares, also called "Naked Shorting" and then failing to deliver the shares. In the US market, they use the term "Failure to Deliver" to describe it. The consequence of this act is to increase the number of outstanding shares of a company and basic economics of demand and supply states that when the supply increases, price goes down.

So, let's say Company A issued 1000 shares. Anyone who owns 1000 of these shares own 100% of company. Let's say a hedge fund "naked short" another 1000 shares and "fails to deliver" it. These 1000 "naked short" shares are credited as electronic digits into the buyer's online brokerage account and are paid for by the buyer. The total number of shares appearing as electronic digits are now 2000 shares, but the number of shares legally issued is only what now? The buyer has effectively paid for nothing! It has been said that such practices resulted in many good fundamentally strong companies being driven to bankruptcy in the US and it is claimed that this is rampant in that country. It is also conservatively claimed that about 1% of daily shares volume traded in the US market are such " phantom shares".

Guess SGX did a fine job to mandate that investors buy back any naked shorted shares in the market within 1 day or else face a fine of $1000.

Read the articles below for more information. Hmm...we wonder how will the companies issue dividends in this case?

Click this for greater understanding.

If you like this blog, do help SGDividends by adding us as your favourites via this link,THANK YOU!:
Add to Technorati Favorites

Important: The objective of the articles in this blog is to set you thinking about the company before you invest your hard-earned money. Do not invest solely based on this article. Unlike House or Instituitional Analysts who have to maintain relations with corporations due to investment banking relations, generating commissions,e.t.c, SGDividends say things as it is, factually. Unlike Analyst who have to be "uptight" and "cheem", we make it simplified and cheapskate. -The Vigilante Investor, SGDividends Team


  1. Stock market manipulation mostly American stock market and its touched markets are very disturbed. In which mostly problem is that how make money.Watch a free video on Gold IRA.

  2. Hey SGDividends team!

    First of all, gotta say I love your site: really taught me how to start going about doing basic FA. Anyway, i'm following the steps in the user friendly guide you issued for basics of investing.
    But I'm having a little problem with S Chips like China Milk and Sinotel etc.

    When I look at your intrinsic values table and also price/FCF, the SG stocks match up. But the ChinaMilk FCF is different from Reuters data? Making me a little confused. (I tried converting from RMB which is given in reuters to SGD but my numbers still don't match yours in the table)

    Also, for Graham's funny formula, when you talk about G, are you referring to future estimated growth over 5,7 years, or your talking about annual EPS growth?

    Thanks so much! Keep up the good work =)

    Young Investor

  3. Hi, I am currently working part time for an advertising company to source for advertising space on Singapore finance blogs. I have recommended your site to my company.

    We have taken a keen interest on it. Are you interested to let them place advertisments on your blog? We will pay you the fees upfront, into your paypal account in SGD. A sample of their advertisement (CFDs investing) has been placed on my blog ( and no clicks or minimum impressions are required.

    Blogs with our ads:

    Do let me know if you are keen and we can discuss the rates over emails. No meeting or tele conversation is required. Please email me at

    Please quote your blog address when you email me. I will reply asap!




Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.